GST on supply of Electricity: GST on Electricity

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) has been a significant reform in India’s taxation system, aiming to create a unified market and simplify tax procedures. However, the application of GST on supply of electricity has its unique considerations. This blog will break down the essentials of GST on electricity, how GST impacts electricity, making it easy to understand for everyone. 

What is the exemption for GST on supply of Electricity?

Electricity is a fundamental necessity for households and industries alike. Recognizing its importance, the Indian government has exempted the supply of electricity from GST. This means when you receive your electricity bill, there is no GST component added to it.

This exemption helps in keeping the cost of electricity lower and more affordable for consumers and businesses, thereby supporting economic activities and reducing the overall cost of living. 

Implications for Power Companies

While the exemption benefits consumers, it poses challenges for electricity generation and distribution companies. These companies incur GST on various inputs such as coal, machinery, and maintenance services required to produce and distribute electricity.

However, due to the exemption on the final product (electricity), they cannot claim Input Tax Credit (ITC) on these inputs. This inability to offset GST paid on inputs against their output tax liability increases their operational costs, which can affect their financial health and pricing strategies. 

Is electricity supply considered Goods or Services under GST?

Electricity supply is classified as a service rather than a good under the GST framework. The primary reason is that electricity is not tangible in the conventional sense, making it more akin to a service.

Consequently, electricity supply falls under the purview of services for tax purposes, and the Indian government has chosen to exempt it from GST to keep electricity costs manageable for consumers and businesses. 

What are the advantages of electricity under GST?

• Uniform Tax Structure:
  • Including electricity under GST would create a uniform tax structure across all sectors, eliminating discrepancies between different states’ VAT and other taxes on electricity. This would simplify compliance and administration. 
• Input Tax Credit Benefits:
  • Power generation and distribution companies would be able to claim ITC on their inputs (like machinery, coal, maintenance services). This would reduce their overall cost of production, potentially leading to lower electricity tariffs for consumers. 
• Boost to Industry:
  • Reduced costs for power companies could encourage more investment in the power sector, leading to improved infrastructure and service delivery. It could also benefit industries that rely heavily on electricity by reducing their input costs. 
• Transparency and Efficiency:
  • Integrating electricity into the GST framework would increase transparency in the taxation process. It would reduce the cascading effect of taxes, making the entire process more efficient. 
• Revenue Generation:
  • Bringing electricity under GST would increase the tax base, potentially increasing government revenue without significantly affecting consumer prices if implemented with appropriate tax rates and ITC provisions. 

GST on Ancillary Services

Although the supply of electricity itself is exempt from GST, ancillary services related to electricity are not. Services such as installation, maintenance, repair, and consultancy for electrical infrastructure are subject to GST. For instance, if a company provides maintenance services for a power plant or an electrical grid, these services will attract GST, and the service providers need to comply with the relevant tax regulations. 

How to calculate GST on the supply of electricity?

Although the supply of electricity itself is exempt from GST, ancillary services related to electricity (like maintenance, repair, installation of equipment, etc.) are subject to GST.

Here’s a general formula to calculate GST on such services: 

GST Amount = (Service Value × GST Rate) / 100 

Where;
Service Value: The cost of the service provided. 
GST Rate: The applicable GST rate for the service (typically 18% for most services). 

Example: Let’s assume you are calculating GST for the installation of a solar panel system, which is considered an ancillary service. The cost of the installation service is INR 50,000, and the applicable GST rate is 18%. 

Service Value: INR 50,000
GST Rate: 18% 
Amount: (50,000 × 18) / 100 = INR 9,000 

So, the GST amount on the installation service would be INR 9,000. 

Total Amount Payable;
To find the total amount payable including GST, you can use the following formula:

Total Amount Payable = Service Value + GST Amount

Using the previous example; Total Amount Payable = 50,000 + 9,000 = INR 59,000. 

Taxation of Electricity generation and supply in India

The taxation of electricity generation and supply in India has seen significant changes over the past decade, especially with the introduction of GST in 2017. Below is a summary of the taxation landscape over the last 10 years. 

Year	Tax Regime	Key Taxes	Applicable Rate	Description
2013	Pre-GST Era	VAT, CST, Excise Duty	5%-25%	Electricity generation and supply were subject to state VAT and CST. Excise duty was applicable to certain equipment used in power generation.
2014	Pre-GST Era	VAT, CST, Excise Duty	5%-25%	Like 2013, state-specific VAT and CST were applied. Exemptions were given in certain states to promote renewable energy.
2015	Pre-GST Era	VAT, CST, Excise Duty	5%-25%	Continued application of VAT and CST with variations across states. Excise duty on inputs and machinery.
2016	Pre-GST Era	VAT, CST, Excise Duty	5%-25%	State-specific taxes persisted. Renewable energy projects continued to receive tax incentives and exemptions.
2017	Transition Year	VAT, CST (until June), GST (from July)	5%-25%	GST was introduced on July 1, 2017. Supply of electricity was exempt under GST, but inputs for electricity generation attracted GST.
2018	GST Era	GST on Inputs, No GST on Supply	Exempt	Supply of electricity remained exempt under GST. Input services and goods attracted GST, complicating ITC for power companies.
2019	GST Era	GST on Inputs, No GST on Supply	Exempt	Same as 2018, with continued challenges around ITC for power generation companies.
2020	GST Era	GST on Inputs, No GST on Supply	Exempt	Focus on renewable energy continued with concessional GST rates on equipment and services related to renewable energy projects.
2021	GST Era	GST on Inputs, No GST on Supply	Exempt	Continued exemption on electricity supply. Ongoing debates about including electricity under GST for uniform taxation.
2022	GST Era	GST on Inputs, No GST on Supply	Exempt	Supply of electricity remains exempt. Discussions about state revenue loss and ITC challenges persist.
2023	GST Era	GST on Inputs, No GST on Supply	Exempt	Status quo maintained. Exemption for electricity supply, with GST applicable on related services and inputs.

Key Points

• Pre-GST Era (2013-2016):
  • Electricity generation and supply were primarily taxed through state-level VAT and CST, along with central excise duties on specific inputs and machinery.
  • States had the autonomy to provide tax exemptions and incentives, especially for renewable energy projects.  
• Transition to GST (2017):
  • GST was implemented on July 1, 2017, bringing a unified tax regime across India.
  • The supply of electricity was exempted from GST, but inputs and services related to electricity generation attracted GST, leading to complexities in claiming ITC.  
• GST Era (2018-2023):
  • The supply of electricity remained exempt from GST, but the inputs and ancillary services related to electricity continued to be taxed under GST.
  • This created financial challenges for power generation companies due to the inability to claim ITC on these inputs. 

Renewable Energy Sector

The renewable energy sector, which includes solar, wind, and other sustainable energy sources, is also impacted by GST, but with some nuances. While the supply of electricity from renewable sources is exempt from GST, the equipment and installation services for setting up renewable energy systems are subject to GST.

The government often provides concessional tax rates on these items to promote the adoption of renewable energy. This dual approach supports environmental sustainability while maintaining a tax base. 

What are the disadvantages of electricity under GST?

• Increased Consumer Costs:
  • If the GST rate on electricity is set too high, it could lead to increased electricity bills for consumers. This would affect both households and industries, possibly leading to higher costs of goods and services. 
• Implementation Challenges:
  • Transitioning electricity supply into the GST framework would require significant changes in billing, accounting, and compliance processes for power companies and regulatory bodies. This transition could be complex and costly. 
• State Revenue Loss:
  • States currently levy their own taxes on electricity, which is a significant source of revenue. Including electricity under GST could lead to revenue losses for states, affecting their finances unless there is a robust mechanism for revenue sharing. 
• Policy and Regulation Conflicts:
  • Different states have varying policies and subsidies related to electricity. Integrating electricity under GST might lead to conflicts and require harmonization of these policies, which could be politically sensitive. 
• Impact on Renewable Energy:
  • The renewable energy sector, which benefits from various state-level incentives and tax exemptions, might face uncertainties and possible reductions in benefits. This could slow down the adoption of renewable energy sources. 

Economic Impact of GST on electricity

The exemption of GST on electricity helps keep electricity bills lower for consumers, which is particularly beneficial for households and small businesses. However, the higher operational costs for power companies due to non-creditable GST on inputs can indirectly influence the electricity tariffs over time. 

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding GST on electricity is crucial for consumers and businesses involved in the power sector. While consumers benefit directly from the exemption, power companies face challenges in managing their costs due to the inability to claim ITC. Staying informed about these aspects can help consumers appreciate the benefits they receive and businesses to strategize better to manage their finances. 

FAQs